Value vs. Moderate Resorts at Disney World
Moderate v. Value Resorts. Many guests planning Walt Disney World trips wonder whether it’s worth saving money or paying extra for better amenities, pools, transportation, dining, etc. This comparison weighs the pros & cons of each tier and gives our verdict as to which accommodations are the best picks for different types of travelers.
For starters, this post assumes you’ve already determined that you want to stay on-site at Walt Disney World and have narrowed your search to these specific categories. If not, you might want to start with a different comparison:Â Off-Site v. On-Site Walt Disney World Hotels.
As for this comparison, we break it down to a bunch of different categories (price, theme, rooms, recreation, dining, transportation) because the ultimate answer as to which is better is going to be [spoiler alert] “it depends.” What it depends on is how important each of the considerations below are to you. With that said, let’s try to analyze the five most important features of Walt Disney World hotels to see where each tier has advantages…
Before we get going, we need to offer a caveats about this overarching comparison:Â it’s really clunky. Arguably, Walt Disney World has outgrown the Value, Moderate, and Deluxe Resort tiers. Nowhere is that more apparent than in these two tiers, which include everything from standard rooms at the All Stars to Family Suites at Art of Animation to Cabins at Fort Wilderness to Executive Suites at Gran Destino Tower that border on luxury accommodations. (Some of them are nicer than Deluxe Resort rooms!)
To the greatest extent possible, we’re going to “smooth over” this range of room categories by focusing on standard options at each resort. This makes things easier for us, and also more practical for you since the standard accommodations are the most common category. Realistically, you’re probably not debating between a barebones room at All Star Sports and an Executive Suite at Gran Destino Tower. If you are…maybe this isn’t the post for you!
Anyway, let’s turn to the comparison categories of Value Resorts versus Moderate Resorts at Walt Disney World…
Price
Standard rooms at all Value Resorts are cheaper than standard rooms at all Moderate Resorts. Again, the Art of Animation Family Suites, Cabins at Fort Wilderness, and various room types in Gran Destino Tower are outliers here in that they’re not an apples to apples comparison with the other hotels in the categories, we won’t give them much consideration.
According to our highly unscientific calculations, Moderate Resorts are about $70 more expensive than Value Resorts per night on average (sometimes less, sometimes more). This difference varies widely based upon season, discounts, etc., but expecting to pay about $70 more per night at a Moderate Resort is a good baseline.
One complicating factor with this comparison is the Skyliner Resorts, which are discussed in greater detail in the transportation section. Just as Moderates cost more than Values, there’s a “Skyliner Surcharge” within each category. As a result, the price difference between a standard room at Coronado Springs is typically much cheaper than one at Caribbean Beach, and between the All Stars and Pop Century.
Conversely, the gap between Coronado Springs and Pop Century often is not as significant. Regardless of the actual number, it’s true that, on average, standard rooms at the Moderates cost more than a good chunk of change more than Values on a nightly basis.
Advantage: Values
Theme
Moderate Resorts generally offer more nuance and subtlety in the way of themed environments. You have a lot of ancillary details that come together to form a cohesive backstory and more convincing environment that transports you away from Walt Disney World. This is especially true at the Port Orleans Resorts, where you can spend a lot of time exploring to pick up on morsels of the theme.
By contrast, the Value Resorts convey their style through larger than life icons. At the All Star Resorts, these are primarily oversized Disney characters. If you’re traveling with kids, don’t underestimate how much they might enjoy these icons. Most adults will be less intrigued by the theming at Value Resorts, which generally attempt to distract from the “boxy” plain, motel buildings that comprise the hotels with the eye-grabbing icons. There is nothing nuanced about the theming at these hotels, and adults will almost always prefer the more engaging, interesting, and oftentimes romantic theming of Moderate Resorts.
Advantage: Moderates
Rooms
On average, standard guest rooms at Moderate Resorts are bigger by about 60 square feet. (Caribbean Beach is even larger.) We have a post that offers a break-down of the size difference of all Walt Disney World hotels.
It used to be the case that the Moderate Resorts had nicer rooms with better bedding and superior themed design. It was also the case that the All Star Resorts were looking tired, with faded and dated decor. That has changed with the most recent room designs, which are relatively consistent at Pop Century and all of the All Stars.
There have been some complaints among Walt Disney World diehards that these rooms are light on theme and feel sterile and cold as a result. While it’s true that they favor function over form, the consensus among regular guests (read: non-fans) has been resoundingly positive. For our part, we love these new rooms, finding them to use space exceptionally well, and having thoughtful features, and more.
Moderates still have a better sense of themed design and feel more upscale and less utilitarian as a result. However, some of these are now feeling tired and overdue for updates. They also lack the same space-saving features found in the new rooms at the Value Resorts, which do help bridge the gap in terms of size.
Really, this comes down to your priorities. Our personal favorite rooms are at Coronado Springs Resort, which offer the best of both worlds. However, we also are big fans of the functionality of the new rooms at the Value Resorts. They don’t have the most elaborate designs, but they really get the job done and serve their purpose well!
Advantage: It Depends
Dining
Each Moderate Resort has a table service restaurant (except French Quarter, but it’s a 10 minute walk from Riverside, and a brief boat ride from Disney Springs), some of which are pretty good. They’re not Deluxe-caliber restaurants (the kind of restaurants that draw non-resort guests to them), but they’re not bad. Basically, they’re good options if want to do dinner at your hotel.
All Moderate and Value Resorts have counter service restaurants. The advantage here also goes to Moderate Resorts, as they offer more varied and interesting menus. By contrast, the food courts at the Value Resorts are much more utilitarian. (Even this has exceptions–the food courts at Pop Century and Art of Animation are both Moderate-caliber.)
This only really matters if you’re going to be at your hotel to eat these meals. We usually eat every meal in the parks or at hotels near the parks, so dining at Moderates and Values is always a non-factor for us. It is a factor when for Deluxes, but usually not these categories. (For example, if you’ll be leaving Disney’s Hollywood Studios for a meal at Yachtsman Steakhouse, for example, staying at the Yacht or Beach Club makes it easy to make a pit stop at your room before or after dinner.)
Advantage: Moderates
Recreation
All Moderates have themed pools with water slides, and each of these pools is pretty cool. Value Resorts also have lightly themed pools, sans slides. Aside from Art of Animation’s Big Blue Pool, no Value Resort Pool made our list of the Top 10 Pools at Walt Disney World, whereas several Moderate pools made the list.
Moderate Resorts also offer bars/lounges and various other forms of activities, like boat rentals, that aren’t available at the Value Resorts. The advantages here universally belong to the Moderate Resorts, which unquestionably have better amenities than the Values.
Without question, the most/best amenities are found at Coronado Springs. This is Walt Disney World’s primary convention hotel, and it shows. That’s why Gran Destino Tower was added, and it has a ton of amenities for adults. Multiple restaurants, bars & lounges, fitness centers, hot tubs, and more. If these things matter most to you, Coronado Springs blows away the competition–it’s more like a Deluxe Resort than a Moderate in this regard.
It’s really more of a question of whether you’ll use use these amenities. If your party will spend a significant amount of time at your hotel each day, these recreation options could be pretty important. It’s also worth noting that, Moderate Resorts are typically more spread out (French Quarter excepted), so if you are firmly opposed to walking, the Value Resorts might be slightly more appealing. Conversely, this added space offers more areas to explore, and the Moderate Resorts are great for a leisurely stroll in the evening or morning, giving them a true resort (rather than hotel) vibe.
Advantage:Â Moderates
Transportation
This is where things get complicated, and the distinction between the Value and Moderate Resorts really breaks down. You might think that transportation is an important amenity, and those paying extra for higher-tier resorts would be rewarded with more efficient transportation. You would be wrong. Transportation is not consistently better at more expensive hotels, especially when it comes to bus transportation.
In reality, this category is all over the place. The worst transportation at any of these resorts is at Coronado Springs, followed closely by Port Orleans Riverside. That’s because both of these larger resorts have internal bus loops, which is tedious and time-consuming. Coronado Springs the worst due to the addition of Gran Destino Tower, which means more people and strain on the buses.
In the middle are the All Star Resorts (all of them). On occasion, these can share bus service to the parks, but we have not experienced that recently–it seems pretty rare now. More importantly, they each have single stops at each resort. The All Star buses can be a wildcard. Sometimes, buses will be dispatched for each resort and will be running quite often, making them incredibly efficient. Other times, there will be huge lines in the morning or otherwise long waits. Our recent experiences with bus service at the All Stars has been generally positive–a big improvement as compared to a few years ago.
It’s a similar story with Port Orleans French Quarter. This resort has a more compact footprint than its sister property, and bus service is generally efficient.
The best transportation is at any of the Skyliner resorts, which include Art of Animation and Pop Century, plus Caribbean Beach. These offer aerial gondola service to Disney’s Hollywood Studios and EPCOT, which is an absolute gamechanger. The downside is that they do offer bus service to Magic Kingdom and Animal Kingdom, where the two Value Resorts have a slight option since Caribbean Beach Resort has an internal bus loop.
The Skyliner is efficient and predictable, so long as you aren’t visiting during storm season. (Even then, we’ll take the Skyliner resorts.) These are not all equal–Caribbean Beach gets the slight edge since this is the Skyliner hub resort, with two stations that are convenient–meaning direct access to both parks.
We place the Skyliner advantage on par with or perhaps slightly above that of the monorail. That’s really saying something, as the monorail resorts are all Deluxes and charge a significant price premium. The advantage of being able to hop aboard a continuously-loading aerial gondola cannot be overstated, making it exceedingly easy to get to EPCOT and DHS for Early Entry, or taking a midday break.
For us, this is the ultimate trump card–and why we’ll usually opt for the Skyliner Resorts over anything else in both of the Value and Moderate Resort categories, unless there’s a significant price difference, unavailability, or discount exclusions. All of those things do happen often, unfortunately. (There are two times of year when the Skyliner is worth less or nothing at all–during the heart of storm season when it can go down for several hours per day and its annual refurbishment, which is typically in January.)
Advantage: Skyliner Resorts, spanning both Value and Moderate Resorts
Verdict
As is probably clear by now, Value versus Moderate Resorts is not a clean comparison. So it thus should not come as a surprise that this is not a neat verdict, with one category being the obvious winner. To the contrary, the outcome is very circumstantial, and often comes down to specific hotels being better options rather than broad categories.
Whether it’s worth it for you to pay more for a Moderate Resort depends upon your preferences, budget, and how much time you’ll be spending at your hotel. If you like a richly themed environment, the Moderate Resorts score points. If you’re primarily interested in how much your kids will enjoy a resort, give the Value Resorts a second look. To the bewilderment of some adults, kids absolutely love those large icons.
If money is an issue, the premium pricing you’ll pay at a Moderate may not make a whole lot of sense. Even then, the surcharge is not equal across the board. Skyliner Resorts are typically more expensive within their respective categories, and there’s also a surcharge for Gran Destino Tower, which is really more like a Deluxe Resort, albeit an isolated not. We warned you at the outset that this is very much an “it depends” topic, and now you should see why that’s totally true.
Ultimately, what we can offer is our personal perspective as we regularly stay at both Value and Moderate Resorts. Assuming we’re doing it for enjoyment and not a resort update, we usually choose Skyliner Resorts for a quick weekend trip or when the parks are our primary focus. Pop Century is my preferred resort for this type of trip, especially when I’m looking for the best value for money.
If our budget is a bit healthier, we choose Caribbean Beach Resort. Its added amenities are nice, as is the convenience of being the Skyliner hub. We also like having access to better dining, even though we (admittedly) often don’t take full advantage of it. Then there’s the pool. Even when we don’t use these things, having access to them is nice.
If it’s a longer trip or we’re looking at stretching our budget further, that’s where the other Value and Moderate Resorts come into play. Thanks to the new rooms, the All Stars have really grown on me, especially at times when they’re not hosting youth events. If I’m doing a longer solo trip, the parks are a priority, or I’m trying to keep costs down, I choose whichever of these is cheapest.
Then there’s Coronado Springs Resort. When we’re traveling together and will be spending a bit more time at the resort, this option usually wins out. Its rooms are better, base rates are lower, discounts are better, and sometimes we luck into an upgrade to Gran Destino Tower. We also prefer the fitness center, pools, and restaurants. We find ourselves doing late night meals at Three Bridges after the parks close quite often, and also love Toledo Steakhouse and the lounges in Gran Destino.
Finally, there are the Port Orleans Resorts. These were once our favorites, and still are exemplars of themed design, with beautiful grounds that make for romantic evening walks. We still very much love the idea of the Port Orleans Resorts, and with each visit, we fall in love with them all over again. But if I’m being honest, we don’t have the same pull to return to any of these as the above options. Each of those have functional advantages, whereas it’s all about the form of Port Orleans. To each their own, though. I certainly wouldn’t discourage anyone from booking the Port Orleans Resorts!
Planning a Walt Disney World trip? Learn about hotels on our Walt Disney World Hotels Reviews page. For where to eat, read our Walt Disney World Restaurant Reviews. To save money on tickets or determine which type to buy, read our Tips for Saving Money on Walt Disney World Tickets post. Our What to Pack for Disney Trips post takes a unique look at clever items to take. For what to do and when to do it, our Walt Disney World Ride Guides will help. For comprehensive advice, the best place to start is our Walt Disney World Trip Planning Guide for everything you need to know!
Your Thoughts
Is it worth it to you to stay at a Moderate Resort, or if you’re paying more, do you just splurge all-out by staying at a Deluxe Resort? Or, do you just save as much money as possible by staying at a Value Resort? Share where you normally choose to stay (and why!) in the comments!
We swear by your blog, Tom – and thanks so much for the always thoughtful posts. We’ve been to DW 4 times.
First time we stayed at Pop Century (pre-Skyliner) and hated it because of the bus overcrowding problem, and also sometimes sound problems with the thin walls.
Second time we upgraded to French Quarter and we liked the resort and access to the boat to Disney Springs, but again, did not like being limited to the bus.
The third time we decided to try Caribbean Beach and LOVED being able to use the skyline for Epcot and Hollywood Studios, but had some problems every time with bus to Magic Kingdom because of the wait time. We also had horrible experiences getting to and from AK the first 3 times, so much so that we didn’t even go this time.
OTOH, now that the Skyliner does go to Pop Century and Art of Animation I am considering giving Pop Century another chance if we decide to go back to DW in the next 4-5 years because the cost to stay in Caribbean Beach is definitely much higher and we don’t tend to use all the extra facilities. Plus the room was remarkably similar to the Best Western I stay at when we go to Disneyland (not kidding) except that at the Best Western, we get a microwave, which we did not get at Caribbean Beach (also not kidding.) So you’ve given lots of great pros and cons, it all makes sense to me!
After staying at most of the resorts, we stay at either the Contemporary or the Yacht Club. Yes, the deluxe costs more. But we only get to vacation at Disneyworld twice each year for a week. The rooms at the Contemporary ate THE best. The vibe of the hotel and the location of the Yacht Club is The best for our family. The rooms at the Contemporary are QUIET and spacious. The Contemporary food options are great and the hotel itself can not be beat. The Yacht Club grounds are wonderful. There are docks, pools everywhere, peaceful porches camellia-lined walkways and boats. The walk-way options for EPCOT and Hollywood Studios and the Boardwalk are so fine. The dining options at the hotel are great plus you can extend the food choices with all that is in EPCOT or Boardwalk. The rooms, although perfectly appointed, are not as spacious or as quiet as those at the Contemporary. We just returned yesterday from the Yacht Club. Have booked the Contemporary for fall. just can’t have ONE favorite.
My daughter and I just got home yesterday after visiting WDW. We booked at All Star Music but when we got there they upgraded us to a family suite which had one double bed and a couch bed. I booked a room with two doubles. I called the front desk about my displeasure they tried to find me another room at a value resort but was unable to do so. They sent us to Port Orleans Riverside at no extra cost as well as gave us a taxi travel voucher free of charge. It was an amazing stay and as a result we will probably never stay at a value resort again. The rooms, transportation and food here was so great. Good call WDW for this upgrade you’ll make your money back in our future visit I’m sure.
I have stayed at both POR as well as Pop Century within the last year and, while I know my experience may be unique, it was a night and day difference! At POR the mousekeeping was wonderful! They folded the towels into fun shapes, hung my daughter’s stuffed animals from the bed to make a cute scene…it was wonderful to come back to it each day. The rooms were always left clean. At Pop Century there were dead spiders in the corners of the room, smelly water in the bottom of our tub upon check-in, and the mousekeeping did not even show up the first two days of our trip at all! On the third day she showed up at 7pm when I had just gotten out of the shower.
At Port Orleans the buildings were further spread out then at Pop so if you don’t like to walk distances that might be something to consider. At the same time the food at the main hall was better at POR so it made the walk worth it most of the time.
The bedding at Pop consisted of a sheet and then something like a sheet but a bit thicker….like 2 sheets sewn together. If you want a thick blanket or comforter bring your own. I asked the main office for one and they brought me more hybrid sheets. POR had comforters. If your child is sensitive to textures or needs weighted blankets this is something to consider.
The showers at both Pop and POR were about the same size, however twice at Pop we had to take cold showers on two different days because we never got hot water. We had just gotten back from the parks and were feeling dirty but could not enjoy getting clean because even when the knob was hard to the left the water came out colder then lukewarm. When we turned the knob the to right it changed to icy cold.
Finally, the walls at Pop are VERY thin! You can hear water running, toilets flushing, conversations. One night a man was coughing in the next room and it woke me up at 2:47 am and kept me up. I had to put pillows over my head to block out the noise. At POR I never heard anything… After a day in the parks with all the noise it was nice to have some quiet.
This being said, it was my experience. Not everyone’s is going to be like mine. I personally would rather pay the extra money each night for a hot shower and a more comfy, bigger bed.
(Note: My visit to Pop was after the upgrades were done to the rooms.)
My niece and I just got back from a week-long stay at Port Orleans French Quarter and really enjoyed the compact size, the food court, and the one bus stop. At check in, we were given the option of having daily housekeeping service OR a $50 gift card. Surprise! Thought I had read everything about this resort, but obviously not. Do all the moderates have this choice? Btw, I chose the gift card.
Yes, most of the hotels offer the gift card now for declining mouse-keeping. We got the gift card at Pop Century this past summer.
Hi can you tell me if the beds in a value are the same size as mod?
I think they were Queens when we stayed at Corando and Port Orleans Riverside.
I feel like the only person who just wasn’t impressed with POR. I think it was just ok and would not stay there again. Maybe it’s because I am from New Orleans, so the theming did nothing for me at all. I did like the food court, though!
While Port Orleans – Riverside does have boat transportation to Disney Springs, it can be subject to river conditions! Because of bridges along the route, high water can cause cessation of boat travel – that happened to us during a trip there! However that will not deter us from staying there again – we love this resort!
It’s genuinely very complex in this full of activity life to listen news on Television, so I simply use internet for that reason, and obtain the most up-to-date news.
I really like reading through a post that can make people think.
Also, thanks for allowing for me to comment!
Admiring the dedication you put into your site and detailed
information you present. It’s nice to come
across a blog every once in a while that isn’t the same old rehashed material.
Excellent read! I’ve bookmarked your site and
I’m adding your RSS feeds to my Google account.
Good blog you’ve got here.. It’s difficult to find quality writing like yours these days.
I honestly appreciate individuals like you! Take care!!
HI,
We are taking our daughter to WDW for her 7th birthday next spring. We will also be toting an infant along with us. We’ll probably spend 2 or 3 days at the Magic Kingdom, then a few days going the other parks in the area. I’m a bit worried about having to carry the baby, the stroller and associated gear on the bus to go everywhere. The Deluxe hotels are ridiculously expensive, though. Which Moderate hotel has the best bus service? If we want to use taxi’s instead, are they generally waiting outside the hotels or do we need to call for one in advance? Are the taxi’s very expensive?
Have you thought about carrying bubs in a sling (or a front lack or whatever) and just grabbing a stroller for hire at the parks?much easier than carting everything back and forward
We stayed at POR and rode the bus service 2 days with stroller. It can be hectic and if you get on late with other parents your stroller may not have a place to store. We had to hold ours (folded up) until we arrived back at our room. It wasn’t terrible but next time we will budget for a rental and leave the stroller in the car. Also we were worried about someone messing with our stroller while on rides but we took our expensive items on the rides with us and small stuff was always waiting on us at the stroller when we returned.
First of all, I love your blog so much! I have read through most (maybe all?) of your trip reports, many of your various articles…it is the best. 🙂 It helped us so much in planning our trip to Tokyo Disney Resort this past spring!
So, obviously this post is very thorough – I appreciate all of the various pros and cons detailed here – but I could still use some help deciding between a Value or a Moderate Resort! (Sorry in advance for the length of this comment!)
As background, we are planning a trip in April 2016 for just my husband and I; we do not have kids yet. The trip will be 10 days total, with the first day being just a travel day, then 9 1/2 days in the parks, then 1/2 day return travel.
In looking at pricing, we are seeing ~$500 difference between the Art of Animation (the Value Resort we are most interested in) vs. the lower end Moderates (any of which we would be interested in), for the dates of our trip. We can afford that amount in our budget, but we’re debating whether to funnel that ~$500 into a nicer resort, or instead into special dining, drinks (maybe Drinking Around the World?!), etc.
We have been to Disneyland Resort a couple times together over the past few years, and to Tokyo Disney Resort this spring, and during those trips we stayed in the parks all day, every day – we never went back to the hotel in the middle of the day, so during those trips our hotel really was just a place to sleep. I’m not absolutely ruling out a mid-day siesta and/or pool time at the resort during some days of this upcoming trip, as our touring style for WDW may end up being different than at DLR or TDR – after all, this trip will be much longer than our previous Disney trips. However, I don’t anticipate spending too much time at the resort. Even when we wanted to take it easy at times on our past trips, we still just stayed in the parks and hung out, explored, take photos, sat down to eat for awhile, etc. We are also interested in visiting and dining at other (cooler) resorts on property throughout our upcoming trip.
My husband thinks this is a no brainer – he thinks we should just stay at one of the cheaper resorts, since he says we’ll mostly just be sleeping there (which has been true of our Disney trips so far), and then we can have more extra money for other fun things to do (probably mostly dining). This is his first ever trip to WDW.
This will be my third trip to WDW – my first trip was in November 1994, when I was 9 years old and my family visited on our big family WDW trip, and my second trip was in spring 2002 with my high school band. I am torn – when I visited with my family, we stayed at the Polynesian and I looooved it! We definitely had a couple/few days where we spent some time at the pool/on the beach, we went to the luau one evening…enjoying all that the Poly has to offer. It was honestly one of the most memorable and magical aspects of that vacation.
In high school I stayed at All Star Music, and really the only particular positive memory I have is playing in the pool late at night with my friends – but we were rowdy teenagers and would have enjoyed any swimming pool and any other late night activities with no adult supervision; this was not in any way particular to that resort. And I remember feeling kind of let down by All Star Music, since all I had to compare it to was the Poly, and thinking “Oh, I guess not all hotels are connected to the monorail loop…and oh, this hotel is not amazing and magical like the Polynesian…I wish we were staying there!” Spoiled, I know. Of course the trip was still super fun, but it did not have that extra level of awesomeness.
Hence, I am torn. I would love to stay in an awesome themed resort, as I know how much this can add to a WDW vacation, but I can see the appeal of having extra money for experiences throughout the trip, and this seems like it might fit our style of touring better…and we certainly can’t afford the Poly and all its glory. Help!!!